Insights | Capstone CFO

Accrual vs. Cash Accounting: Which Method Is Right for Your Business? | Capstone CFO

Written by Capstone CFO | Jan 9, 2025, 6:24:58 PM

TL;DR: cash accounting records income and expenses when money moves; accrual accounting records them when they are earned or incurred. Cash is simpler, but accrual shows true profitability and is what lenders, investors and buyers expect. Most growing companies, especially those with inventory, contracts, investors or a sale on the horizon, should keep their books on an accrual basis, while the CPA chooses the best method for tax.

How each method works

Cash accountingAccrual accounting
Revenue recordedWhen the customer paysWhen it is earned (for example, when you invoice for delivered work)
Expenses recordedWhen you pay the billWhen the cost is incurred
Tracks receivables and payablesNoYes
Best forVery small, simple service businessesGrowing companies, inventory, contracts, investors, lenders
Main weaknessProfit swings with payment timingNeeds a separate view of cash flow

Example: you invoice $50,000 for work completed in December and the customer pays in February. Under cash accounting, the revenue appears in February. Under accrual accounting, it appears in December, the month the work was done.

Who must use accrual?

  • For financial statements: statements prepared under U.S. GAAP, which banks, investors and buyers usually expect, are accrual-based.
  • For taxes: C corporations, and partnerships with a C corporation partner, generally must use accrual once their average annual gross receipts exceed an inflation-indexed threshold, $31 million for 2025. Tax shelters must use accrual regardless of size.
  • Inventory: businesses with inventory face additional rules, although many smaller businesses qualify for simplified options.

How to choose

  • Cash can work if you are small, have no inventory, are paid quickly and have no outside investors or lenders.
  • Accrual is the better choice if you bill on terms, recognize revenue over time, carry inventory, have investors or lenders, or plan to raise capital or sell.
  • Many companies use both: accrual books for management and reporting, with the tax return prepared on the method your CPA recommends.

Pros and cons at a glance

  • Cash, pros: simple; mirrors the bank balance; can help with tax timing.
  • Cash, cons: misleading profit picture; no view of receivables or payables; often not accepted by lenders or investors.
  • Accrual, pros: true profitability by month; matches revenue with the costs that produced it; credible with lenders, investors and buyers.
  • Accrual, cons: more work; requires good month-end processes; cash still needs its own forecast.

Switching from cash to accrual

  1. Talk with your CPA about the tax side; a change in tax method is generally filed with IRS Form 3115.
  2. Record opening receivables, payables, prepaid expenses and accrued liabilities.
  3. Set up a monthly close that includes accruals and reconciliations.
  4. Add a 13-week cash flow forecast so you keep a clear view of cash.

Frequently asked questions

Can I switch accounting methods?

Yes. For your management books you can switch at any time. For taxes, a change generally requires filing Form 3115 with the IRS; many changes qualify for automatic consent. Your CPA can advise.

Is accrual accounting better for getting a loan?

Usually. Lenders generally want accrual-based statements, and larger facilities often require reviewed or audited financials.

Can my books be accrual while my taxes are cash?

Often, yes, if your business qualifies to use the cash method for tax. Your CPA reconciles the two at year-end.

This article is general information, not tax or accounting advice. Review your situation with your CPA.

Need help moving to accrual books and a faster close? See how we fix late or inaccurate financials or book a call with our CFO team.