Insights | Capstone CFO

What’s Eating Into Your Profit Margins? | Capstone CFO

Written by Capstone CFO | Nov 14, 2024, 12:55:42 AM

TL;DR: margins usually shrink for a handful of reasons: prices that have not kept up with costs, a mix shift toward less profitable customers or products, discounting, rising labor and overhead, and waste hiding in operations. The fix starts with seeing gross margin by customer, product and channel, then acting on the few drivers that matter most.

Gross margin vs. net margin

  • Gross margin = (revenue − direct costs) ÷ revenue. It shows how profitable your product or service is.
  • Net margin = net profit ÷ revenue. It shows what is left after overhead, interest and taxes.

If gross margin is falling, look at pricing, direct costs and mix. If gross margin is stable but net margin is falling, look at overhead.

Seven common margin killers

  1. Stale pricing. Costs rose; prices did not.
  2. Discounting creep. Exceptions became the norm, often without approval.
  3. Unprofitable customers. Small accounts with heavy service demands, or big accounts with deep discounts.
  4. Product or service mix. Growth concentrated in lower-margin offerings.
  5. Labor inefficiency. Low utilization, overtime or rework.
  6. Overhead growth. Software, rent and administrative headcount growing faster than revenue.
  7. Leakage. Unbilled work, missed change orders, write-offs and shrinkage.

How to find the leaks

  • Build profitability by customer, product and channel.
  • Compare actual prices with list prices to measure discounting.
  • Trend gross margin monthly and explain every major move.
  • Benchmark overhead as a percentage of revenue against your own history.

Fixes that work

  • A structured price increase, segmented by customer value and sensitivity
  • Discount approval rules
  • Minimum order sizes or service fees for small accounts
  • Vendor renegotiation and consolidation
  • Automation of repetitive work

Frequently asked questions

What is a good profit margin?

It depends heavily on industry. Compare against your own trend and peers in your sector rather than a general rule.

Should we cut costs or raise prices first?

Usually pricing, because it has the biggest and fastest effect. Cost cuts follow where there is clear waste.

How often should we review margins?

Monthly, with a deeper customer and product review each quarter.

Margins under pressure? See how to raise prices without losing customers or book a call with our CFO team.